Not resolved

Fiduciary duty is alive and well at Etrade--the duty is to themselves and the opponent is the client base.

Their margin department refused to disclose their basis for required margin adjustments. They drastically raised the required collateral (in one case, leverage moved from 4X to 1.5X overnight). When I requested information on historical margin call alerts, they claimed to delete records after six months.

The margin calls are OPPORTUNISTIC. They were not dependent upon day-to-day or trending volatilities. The initial margin was generous, and the portfolio volatility low. However, Etrade's margin department prepares for moments when they can profitably call against you. When they do, be sure that they are your trading partner on the other side.

Had an Experience with Etrade?

Write a review


Terms of Service
Post Comment

Never had a problem, but I can see why the above would.This world is volatile even if you don't realize it.

Margin requirements change constantly and often etrade is just compliant in the chance. Some securities may be 2:1, 1:1, .5:1 marginal. Sometimes this is determined by the SEC, sometimes by a price change. If you're *** enough to get caught in a margin call, you have 5 days to meet it before they liquidate your assets.

Never use more then 50% margin, period.That allows your entire portfolio to drop by 50% before you have to GTFO.


I lost 600+ shares of Apple in a Margin call when the market dropped a few years ago. While they could have either asked me what to sell or sold something else they chose to "satisfy my margin requirements" by selling the best stock I had. It was $90 when they sold it, so the loss is north of $250,000


I lost a lot of money because of the way they process margin calls. They did not send me an email, rather posted a message to their internal messaging system, which is curious given that they collect some much info on you.

You May Also Like

World Financial Group - Transamerica *KEEPS* Your FFIUL Money When You Die World Financial Group "A shocking dirty little secret of Universal Life policies: you LOSE all your policy's cash value when you croak. This is true of Transamerica’s Financial Foundation Indexed Universal Life (FFIUL)..." Read more World Financial Group - WFG is a Great Way to Go BROKE and LOSE FAMILY and FRIENDS World Financial Group "Mr/Ms WFG No-name from Nowhere. Please spare us your big fat lie about "many big earners" at WFG. It's total bull cr*p and you know it. Here I give you..." Read more World Financial Group - Hampton Bay Anon. You confirm how AWFUL the FFIUL is. World Financial Group "HB Anon, for all your righteous high-flown talk about "...Loss of cash value ...never has been deceptive..." isn't it funny how so few people--including most of the WFG agents..." Read more World Financial Group - My God! People, Run - FLEE, FAST AS YOU CAN - From This Nightmare!!! World Financial Group "Not trying to kill your dreams here. I’m trying to -save- you, your families, your friendships, and your money from this endless soul-sucking NIGHTMARE. I worked full-time for WFG in..." Read more Lazada Philippines - Refund money and broke item Lazada Philippines "Im really dissapointed in my order in lazada because i cannot use my order because when they deliverd and i try to use but its broke, this is 2x i..." Read more Once again  Gasbike got me!!  my own fault for expecting anything different Gasbike "ordered a motor.. did not leave their place for 3 DAYS! took 10 days to get to me... AND they put a direct signature clause on the package !! nobody..." Read more Mingle2 - I can't send messages to my friend and my friends cant send message too. i don't know why Mingle2 "i dont know whats going on with my account. anytime i'm trying to send my friends message it always show me. We need additional information from you to prove you..." Read more Lasership - Horrendous Lasership "Lasership messed up one of my Sephora orders, erroneously sending it from MA where I live, to Virginia, then back to MA. I didn't get it for another week, and..." Read more